Foreign Courts Wary of U.S. Punitive Damages
|
|
In late summer 1985, Kurt Parrott, a 15-year-old who loves baseball and Pac-Man, was thrown from his vehicle in Opelika, Ala. of the loop not his helmet, and he died when his head uncovered on the sidewalk. Mr. Parrott mother of the Italian company cites the helmet, and an Alabama court awarded him $ 1 million. The company has refused to pay. And during the past year, as agents of the family in Italy Parrott is trying to gather, they were by the Italian Supreme Court. The court stated that the specificity of American law - punitive damages - it was inappropriate to perceptions of the Italian justice system, that it is not the implementation of the Alabama ruling. Much of the rest of the world sees the idea of punitive damages alarm. As the Italian court said that private action, the injured should have one goal - compensation for the loss. Let distinct distinction served on the defendant to punish foreign courts say, is a horrible spectacle. Sanctions, they say, must be measured solely by the criminal justice system for his costly process because altruistic and prohibits prosecutors. It is not fair, they complement one another to give an applicant wind case beyond what they have lost. And this ad hoc advice from a jury, they say, are a poor substitute for the decisions by governments and regulators security. Some countries, often the law allows punitive damages, but under certain conditions and modest amounts. In the United States, however, huge punitive prices are relatively common, although they are often reduced or eliminated on the right of appeal. Last month, for example, the United States Supreme Court heard arguments from the Exxon Valdez, where a jury, the initial price of $ 5 billion from the United States was subsequently reduced to $ 2.5 billion. Still, frighten distinctions such as foreign courts. “The practice of the United States allows a jury of laypersons largely discretionary exercise with a limited number of restrictions on standing in the award of punitive damages is almost everywhere outside the United States, with a high degree of denouncing, “said Gary Born, an American lawyer, works in London. Lawyers and judges are quick to cite particularly large American distinctions. Julian Lew, a lawyer in London, recalled a Mississippi court’s $ 400 million punitive award against a Canadian company in the year 1995 with contempt. “There were a total of setting America and the complete disregard in the world,” said Dr. Lew. |